Florida PlumberCheck

Replacing a water heater in Florida: what to ask the plumber

Tank or tankless, gas or electric, permits, drain pans and the questions that separate a complete quote from a bare one.

A water heater usually fails at an inconvenient time, and the plumber you call that day often gets the job. A few minutes of preparation, ideally before the heater dies, keeps the replacement from becoming the most expensive plumbing decision you make in a year.

Know what you have

Look at the label on the tank. It shows the capacity, the fuel type (electric, natural gas or propane), the model and serial number, and often the manufacture date. Tank-style heaters commonly last about ten to fifteen years, depending on water quality and maintenance, and many Florida homes have heaters that are older than that. Signs of failure include rusty hot water, rumbling noises, and moisture at the base. Water pooling around the tank means it is time to act, not to wait.

Write the label details in your phone now. When you call for quotes, the plumber can price a like-for-like replacement over the phone, and you can compare two or three answers in an afternoon instead of accepting the first truck that arrives.

Tank or tankless

A tank heater stores and keeps hot water ready; a tankless unit heats water as it flows. Tankless units cost more to buy and install, can take up less space, and may need larger gas lines or a bigger electrical circuit. That is where a quote can balloon. If someone proposes tankless, ask for the line items for the gas line, venting, electrical work and any condensate drain, and compare them with a quote for a like-for-like tank.

Who is allowed to do the work

Replacing a water heater is plumbing work, and Florida's definition of a plumbing contractor includes water lines, natural gas and liquefied petroleum gas lines, and the related venting (section 489.105). The same definition carves out two cases that matter for gas heaters: a propane dealer or installer licensed under Chapter 527, and an employee of a natural gas utility, may disconnect and reconnect the water lines when servicing or replacing an existing water heater without a plumbing licence. So a licensed propane company or the gas utility may legitimately do a straight swap; a general handyman is not covered by that carve-out. For anything beyond a swap, such as moving the heater, adding a gas line or converting to tankless, use a licensed plumbing contractor and check the number on DBPR's Verify a License page.

What a complete quote includes

Permits

Replacing a water heater is regulated work under the Florida Building Code, and building departments in Florida generally require a permit and an inspection. Ask whether the permit is included in the price and who pulls it. The permit should be in the contractor's name. If a plumber says it is not needed or asks you to pull it yourself, ask why before you agree, because the permit is part of how the installation gets checked.

Fuel and safety

Gas water heaters need proper venting to carry exhaust outdoors, and combustion air. A poorly vented gas heater can release carbon monoxide into the home. Work on gas piping and venting should be done by a licensed contractor; ask who is licensed to do it, and install a carbon monoxide alarm. For an electric heater, the circuit and breaker must match the unit's rating; a licensed electrician may be needed if the circuit has to change.

Temperature

Many manufacturers recommend setting the heater around 120 degrees Fahrenheit to reduce scald risk. Households with young children or older adults should pay attention to that setting. Ask the plumber to set and show you the temperature at the end of the job.

Payment and the 10 percent rule

For residential work, a contractor who collects more than 10 percent of the price up front must apply for permits within 30 days and start within 90 days after permits issue, unless there is just cause or you agree in writing to longer periods (section 489.126). On a one-day job, there is usually no reason to pay much before the work is done. Pay by a traceable method and keep the invoice and permit number with your warranty paperwork. If the heater is under a manufacturer's warranty, ask whether the plumber handles the claim.

When the price passes $2,500

A straight tank swap is often a small contract, but a tankless conversion with new gas piping and venting can cross $2,500, and that number matters. Above it, a residential contract must include the Florida Homeowners' Construction Recovery Fund notice (section 489.1425) and the construction lien law warning that unpaid suppliers can claim against your property (section 713.015). If a larger quote arrives without either notice, ask for a revised contract before you sign, and ask for a lien release from the supplier of the heater when you make the final payment.

After the install

Before the plumber leaves, run hot water at the farthest tap, look at every new joint for drips, and check that the relief valve has a discharge pipe and that nothing blocks its outlet. Keep the permit number, the final inspection result and the heater's serial number with the warranty card, and register the heater if the manufacturer requires it. Put a note on the calendar for the maintenance steps in the owner's manual, such as flushing sediment.

Updated 2026-10-03.

General information only, current as of the date above. The information on Florida Plumber Check is not a recommendation or a guarantee of anyone's work. A license record shows registration status on the date shown, not workmanship, insurance coverage at the time of your job, or suitability for your project. Confirm license, insurance and permits directly before you hire. Rules and programs change; check the official sources linked in this guide.

Find plumbers